Cuyana Oversized Alpaca Sweater Review

Last updated on January 2nd, 2021 at 10:14 pm

Cuyana Oversized Alpaca Sweater Review

Above: Top – Cuyana via Poshmark; Bottom – Mott & Bow jeans; Shoes – Birdies Ani Slides; Bag – Lo & Sons Pearl crossbody

As usual, I had been eyeing the Cuyana Oversized Alpaca Sweater for a while… I feel like this opening phrase is now standard for most of my review posts. I’m trying to be more conscious about what I add to my closet these past few seasons. I try to adhere to a one-in-one-out policy, though there are exceptions if I really love a piece and it’ll be something I wear regularly. When possible, I also try to buy second-hand – sometimes, this is my only choice if I’m looking for a retired piece like the retired Everlane silk tanks.

This review is for the Petite version of the Oversized Alpaca Sweater – unfortunately, Cuyana no longer makes it in Petite and now has two sizes: XS/S and M/L. I tried on the XS/S in the San Francisco store, and found it just a bit too loose and baggy, despite that being the style. After stalking the internets for weeks, I was excited to see someone selling the shorter Petite version on Poshmark. I quickly snagged it for $75 + shipping instead of the usual $185.

Size & Fit

I found this style to be the perfect oversized fit – large enough to drape well, but not so large that I feel like I am swimming in it. The length is shorter in the front than the back – the back covers my butt loosely. I am 5’4” and normally a size 2, X-Small or Small in tops, depending on the style and the brand. For reference, I wear Everlane t-shirts and sweaters in size Small and Everlane blouses in 2. If you are a size 4-6 or taller than I am, then the XS/S will work likely well for you.


This top is 100% Baby Alpaca Wool – I find non-cashmere wool to be hit or miss. Some irritate my skin while others don’t. For the most part, this top is itch-free, though my skin does get irritated every now and then. I would say its itchiness grade is somewhere in between cashmere and merino wool – not nearly enough to be a dealbreaker.


For years, I used to be a devoted dry cleaner. But now that I know I can wash silks and wool without screwing them up, I try to save dry cleaning for the occasional, seasonal clean or when I really need something pressed. When I first received the top, there were two small spots that looked removable so I decided to hand wash and lay flat to dry. It washed perfectly, and now feels even more comfortable on my skin without causing any irritations.


So far, so good! I see this being a staple in my daily wardrobe, and will update this post in a few months to share how it wears over time.


Im Kristy, a marketer based in sometimes-sunny San Francisco ⛅ This is my personal blog, where you will find my random musings, in-depth reviews, and latest sewing endeavors.

Recent Posts




This site uses affiliate links. Clicking on or purchasing via an affiliate link may result in commissions for this site. You may read more about this in the privacy policy.